Emmerdale fans think they might have cracked the case as bookies have dramatically slashed the odds on a very unusual suspect.
Just over a week before the big reveal in a special flashback episode, vicar Ashley Thomas has become a hot favourite to be unmasked as the gunman.
Yep, you know Ashley? Mild mannered, religious chap who forgave a girl for running him over?
Betfair have picked up on the growing belief that Ashley shot Robert and cut the odds down from 100/1 all the way down to 5/1, which makes him second favourite to have pulled the trigger behind only Ross Barton, who remains favourite at 2/1. It makes him equally as likely as Paddy Kirk to have shot Robert, according to the odds.